Why The CIDs Will Suffer.

Posted on 31 March 2010 by



Written, 29th-31st March.

When the iPhone launched, it entered a pre-existing smartphone market. It was a great event for consumers because manufacturers in that market were forced to play catch-up which meant great options and deals for customers. In the Consumer Internet Device space of the iPad, the landscape is different. This time round Apple have stepped into a relatively new market and set up shop alone. There they sit with their complete product offering (at a great price) and wait for competitors. They’re likely to be waiting a long time because the iPad outshines anything we’ve seen in prototype form from anyone else by a huge margin and it would be safe to assume that every financial director responsible for a consumer handheld product has put the brakes on their own products. It means that instead of manufacturers increasing their efforts to put new devices out there, many of the new products will get held up, or even canned. For the smaller companies like ICD, Fusion Garage and Notion Ink, this could be catastrophic as investors re-asses the opportunity. If they are lucky, some of the prototype products will end up going back to the drawing board where the system integrators will be pondering long and strong over their app-stores and content offerings. The big problem here though is that there isn’t an OS or application ecosystem out there that can compete. I can’t think of any worthy alternative to the iPhone /iPad OS right now.

Forget any unknown (outside geek circles) Linux distributions because they lack a reputable app-store or focused developer community. Forget Maemo, Moblin or MeeGo because they won’t be ready until much later in the year. Forget any new unknown proprietary OS because the customer won’t trust it and the developers won’t be interested. Forget Windows 7 because it’s a big fat heavy blob that can’t keep up with finger-driven social, photo and location-aware applications. Even Android isn’t good enough and it’s worth discussing why.

I use Android on a daily basis and enjoy it a lot. The Archos 5 is a fantastic internet device but it highlights why Android is useless. Android doesn’t have a marketplace. The Android you’re thinking of is ‘Google’  Android and it makes a huge difference to the product.

The Marketplace and other closed-source, approval-required Google apps is what makes Android tick and any Android tablet that tries to enter the marketplace without it is committing suicide. The disappointment experienced by people when they can’t sync their mail or even populate their contacts application, access Google Maps, Buzz and other key apps will kill any momentum a device ever had. The problem is, these manufacturers are finding it difficult to get the marketplace and add it into Android. Google don’t appear to be  ready to expand outside the smartphone arena.  Maybe they’re scared of splintering Android. More splintering of the platform could upset developers and cause more application incompatibility problems and that would be an even bigger problem.

Mobinnova Beam, Archos 7 Home Tablet, Compaq AirLife 100 and other devices that I can’t talk about here are all going to hit a brick wall if they don’t get that app-store sorted out.

Right now, there isn’t an easy solution unless you’re a huge company with influence. Someone like Dell can make an oversize phone called the Dell Mini 5 and invest in the carrier deals, licensing, firmware support and certification processes that make Marketplace possible. That’s one product out of, what, 50 or so tablets, MIDs and smartbooks that we’ve seen at Computex, CES, CeBIT, MWC, CTIA and other shows. Even HP Compaq haven’t been able to achieve it with the AirLife.

If I was building a tablet I’d be praying for Google to free-up that marketplace and app-suite and I would be praying that my investors didn’t pull out during the waiting period. That waiting period is unknown right now and investors really don’t like broken critical paths without a fix date.

The iPad has already conquered this new market and consumers looking for an alternative handheld device will have to wait and pray that Google, Nokia and Intel; with their Marketplace, OVI and AppUp stores, accelerate their work and get a solution to the integrators before time runs out.  Palm’s WebOS could be an option to look at too.

Watch out for Archos in the summer because their PMP, MID and tablet strategy hinges 100% on Android. If it comes with Marketplace, we can all  breath again. If not, we might as well all buy an iPad and have some fun while we wait for 2011.

CID = Consumer Internet Device.

Categorized | Report

Tags : , , ,

4 Comments For This Post

  1. Thomas says:

    Google has been pretty evil about the marketplace, but I don’t think anyone can say CID’s are gone quite yet. There is still a lot of hope left out there. From my days with maemo and now with android, I know there is a huge possibility for someone to make a great CID. It just hasn’t been done yet. All the potential in the world is there, it’s just not quite done yet. The closest I’ve seen is the dell streak, archos 5, or Sharp IS01. And the viliv pmp they showed off at CES might stand a chance as well.

    I think google will smart up and finally start giving away marketplace support for CID’s.

  2. gmich says:

    Thanks for another thoughtful piece, Chippy. As someone who has consciously avoided the Apple bandwagon (except for my iPod Nano), I’ve been telling myself that I would shun the iPad as well. I currently have an Archos 5 Android, and despite its continued instability issues I’ve really enjoyed it. I love the form factor, the size, and with a simple hack I can at least get free Google apps. But after reading all the reviews of the iPad, I broke down, got up at 6am to stand in line, and bought one today. And let me say, based on a few hours of usage, your assessment is right on target. It doesn’t do everything — the lack of Flash, of course, and the absence of multitasking are two biggies — but what it does it does exceedingly well, and with a polish and ease of use that just isn’t found on other MIDs/CIDs. The browsing experience is awesome, and many of the other apps are as well. And I agree with you that Apple is going to leave everybody else behind unless Google will open up the app store — if they do, the Dell Streak could be a contender.

    And that brings me to the one thing about the iPad that, to me, just misses the mark: it’s a little too big and a little too heavy. I think a 5″-7″, 1 lb. or under “iPad mini” would be amazing. As is, it gets kind of heavy in your hand, and it’s not anywhere close to being pocketable. I wouldn’t be surprised if Apple comes out with a 6″ or 7″ mini version for the holidays.

    I can’t help thinking, th

  3. eyetoy webcam software download says:

    The bad advantage of using this place on a consecutive basis is that it bottom provide you with convenient functions; this internet site was intentional to save your money and time and you are not potential to be scammed when trying to download digital data. This online directory behind provide you with a genuine collection of PC political programs; this collection will come along with a wide variety of benefits.

  4. Jessica says:

    The iPad has already conquered this new market and customers in search of an alternative handheld machine must wait and pray that Google, Nokia and Intel; with their Marketplace, OVI and AppUp shops, accelerate their work and get an answer to the integrators before time runs out. Palm’s WebOS could be an possibility to have a look at too.

2 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. ‘In Other News…’ April 7th | UMPCPortal - Ultra Mobile Personal Computing says:

    [...] Why The CIDs Will Suffer.. The iPad is a complete product at a breakthrough price and the competition that has been waiting [...]

  2. A Smart ‘Pad’, Smart ‘Book’ or a Netbook? (Introducing the Mobile Device ‘Chooser’ Tool) | UMPCPortal - Ultra Mobile Personal Computing says:

    [...] but the biggest one is the iPad which is one of the smartest devices around. It has single-handedly frozen the market for other ‘smart devices’ and scared manufacturers into thinking about how good their devices [...]