Why I Chose the Eee Pad Transformer over the Iconia W500 Tablet

Posted on 03 August 2011, Last updated on 03 August 2011 by

Two devices recently stood out as a different kind of productivity solution, both offering the ability to convert between a tablet and a netbook. The choice is between the Asus Eee Pad Transformer and the Acer Iconia W500.  The Eee Pad runs Android Honeycomb while the Acer runs windows 7.

Both offer the ability to convert from a 10 inch tablet to a laptop style device with a keyboard and mouse. The Asus has a multitouch trackpad while the Acer has a pointing stick style mouse mover.

The units are comparable in features, specs and pricing. The main difference? Windows versus Android, and perhaps battery life. 4 hours for a tablet is pretty ordinary and no where near the Eee Pad’s 10 to 17 hours as a tablet or attached to the dock.

I miss OneNote and that makes me consider Windows tablets but while I could handle 3-4 hours battery life in the old days I’ve now been spoiled by modern day tablets and even netbooks or smaller latops like the Vaio T series which give 7+ hours easily and sometimes more than 10.

Evernote on Android has come a long way as well and while it lacks some of OneNote’s Office suite integration it is now a much more powerful note-taking tool.

One design issue is that the Acer W500 cannot be folded like a laptop while joined to the dock.You have to detach the tablet part, close the docking connector and then clip the tablet over the keyboard. It seems a little ill thought out and since we’re so used to closing up our devices in this way, it may lead to damage.

I disagree with reviews that argue Windows 7 isn’t touch or tablet friendly and in fact I’d say it is the best windows yet for tablet and touch use. But the Iconia doesn’t have a an active or pen enabled screen. It’s capacitive touch and that removed the last killer feature that would have made me buy it. The strength for me of OneNote on a tablet (and even Office as a suite) is that you can ink in it. Without the ability to use a “proper” pen, the Iconia W500 becomes just another tablet, with less battery life and all the issues of Windows including susceptibility to hacking and virus attacks and lacking the advantages of cheap, productivity enhancing apps. So it’s the Asus transformer for me.

 

Recommended Reading

Most-viewed handheld PCs. Updated daily.

GPD Pocket 2
7.0" Intel Core m3-8100Y
Viliv N5
4.8" Intel Atom Z520
GPD Win 2
6.0" Intel m3 7Y30
ASUS T100
10.0" Intel Atom Z3740
Microsoft Surface Go
10.0" Intel Pentium 4415Y
Intel Hades Canyon NUC
0.0" Intel Core i7-8809G
Acer Chromebook 11 CB3-131
11.6" Intel Celeron N2807
Asus Chromebook Flip
10.1" Rockchip RK3288
Sony VAIO Z Series 2012
13.1" Intel Core 3rd Generation (2012)
ASUS Zenbook UX305
13.3" Intel Core M 5Y10a