Greene on MIDs and Tablets.

Posted on 21 February 2008, Last updated on 09 November 2019 by

Jonathan Greene has written a nice piece on the Nokia Internet Tablets today. He makes some comparisons with Intel MIDs which is well worth reading and I agree with most of it.

  • Nokia’s vision for the Internet tablet is good.
  • The N810 is more pocketable than most MIDs
  • Adding horsepower is not the answer to a positive user experience
  • “the multi-part strategy in the Nokia Internet Tablet platform is very compelling for those seeking advanced connectivity, entertainment and productivity”

This is not the whole equation of course, but the points are important ones.

For example, in the really high-volume market for mobile communications I don’t think the customers will want a single, large device like the SE Xperia, Nokia e90 or HTC Advantage. People want one small phone with a camera, ‘texting’, music features and possibly GPS-related features. They might want to get some cool Internet-capable apps on their screens too and that will probably be about it for the next 3 years.

Some of these people will want video and Internet though and this is where the two-device strategy comes into play. Just like some people carry a reading book, PMP or Walkman, this subset will be looking for a second device that gives them the video and Internet.

It looks like Nokia will be a big player in this multi-part strategy and as I’ve said before, I think ARM-based platforms could gain a lot of early wins but as time goes on and as the market matures into mainstream, the x86-based devices will be there too. The software, size and battery life gap will close because all parties understand that these are important issues to solve. We’ll see some excellent devices from both sides.

As customers, I think we’re always going to be winners because those 4 points above seem to be understood by most players now and to us, it really doesn’t matter what’s under the hood as long as it works to our expectations.

1 Comments For This Post

  1. Kong says:

    Well I think adding horsepower will definitely improve the user experience on the N810. Users are complaining that webpages are rendered slowly, videos are choppy and Flash playback isn’t smooth.

    I think all N810 users would want to see the N810 upgraded to a more powerful processor like a 600MHz Cortex-A8.

    However from what I can gather from reviews, the biggest problem facing Nokia’s ITs is software related. It is non-intuitive, buggy and generally too complex for most consumers. If Intel gets Moblin right, Nokia is going to have some tough competiton.

Popular mobile computers on UMPCPortal

  1. 1HP Elitebook 820 G212.5" Intel Core i5 5300Uup 2 places this week2
  2. 2Medion Akoya S221811.6" Intel Atom Z3735Fup 40 places this week40
  3. 3Dell Latitude E744014" Intel Core i5-4200Uup 6 places this week6
  4. 4Acer Aspire E11 ES111.6" Intel Celeron N2840up 2 places this week2
  5. 5ASUS T10010" Intel Atom Z3740up 22 places this week22
  6. 6Acer Aspire Switch 1010.1" Intel Atom Z3745up 3 places this week3
  7. 7GPD Pocket 27" Intel Core m3-8100Yup 6 places this week6
  8. 8ASUS eee pc 7017" Intel Celeron-Mup 13 places this week13
  9. 9Acer Chromebook 1515.6" Intel Celeron N2830up 69 places this week69
  10. 10ASUS Zenbook UX30513.3" Intel Core M 5Y10adown 3 places this week3
  11. 11Viliv N54.8" Intel Atom Z520up 78 places this week78
  12. 12Acer Aspire One 72211.6" AMD C60up 19 places this week19
  13. 13Asus E20211.6" Intel Pentium N3700up 50 places this week50
  14. 14Acer TravelMate B11311.6" Intel Core i3up 342 places this week342
  15. 15Acer V3-37113.3" Intel Core i3 4158Uup 29 places this week29
  16. 16Acer C74011.6" Intel Celeron 3205Udown 12 places this week12
  17. 17Toshiba Portege Z93013.3" Intel Core i5 3427Uno change this week
  18. 18Viliv S54.8" Intel Atom (Silverthorne)up 180 places this week180
  19. 19Acer Aspire One D25010.1" Intel Atomup 112 places this week112
  20. 20UMID M1 MID4.8" Intel Atom (Silverthorne)up 36 places this week36

Devices readers came to UMPCPortal for over the last four weeks (from search engines and other sites), updated daily. Lines: the last 30 days.

Find ultra mobile PCs, Ultrabooks, Netbooks and UMPCs quickly using the following links: